Let's be honest, tax returns can feel like trying to solve a puzzle where half the pieces are missing and the picture on the box keeps changing. If you've ever stared at your self-assessment form wondering whether you've accidentally claimed your morning coffee as a business expense (spoiler alert: you probably can't), you're not alone.
Making mistakes on your tax return is more common than you might think. Even the most organised business owners sometimes slip up, whether it's forgetting to include that freelance project from last March or getting confused about what counts as a legitimate business expense. The good news? Most mistakes can be sorted out without too much drama, provided you know what to do and when to do it.
But here's the thing, whilst HMRC understands that people make honest errors, they're not quite as forgiving when it comes to careless mistakes or, worse still, deliberate attempts to dodge tax. The penalties can range from a gentle slap on the wrist to something that'll make your wallet weep.
So, what happens if you make a mistake on your tax return? How long will it take to fix it? And what can you do to avoid finding yourself in this situation again? Let's break it all down in more detail.
Before we get into the nitty-gritty of fixing mistakes, let's look at the most common slip-ups that land business owners in hot water. Think of this as your "what not to do" guide – because prevention is always better than cure.
Effective tax management starts with good record-keeping. Unfortunately, many small business owners struggle with disorganised records, leading to avoidable inaccuracies in their tax returns.
Common mistakes:
How to get it right:
At Virtue Accountants, we offer tailored bookkeeping services to ensure your financial records are accurate and HMRC-compliant. With our help, you'll never have to worry about missing a key detail again.
Not knowing what you can or cannot claim is one of the most common tax challenges for small business owners. Claim too much, and you risk a flagged audit. Claim too little, and you might be paying more tax than you need to.
Examples of incorrect claims:
What you can do:
With Virtue Accountants, you’ll have a trusted guide to walk you through expense claims, ensuring compliance while helping reduce your tax liability.
Late submissions of tax returns and payments aren't just stressful, they come with hefty penalties and interest charges. Missing deadlines for VAT, self-assessment, or corporation tax is surprisingly common among busy business owners.
Why deadlines get missed:
How to stay ahead:
At Virtue Accountants, we take a proactive approach by tracking your deadlines to ensure all HMRC filings are submitted on time.
VAT may seem straightforward, but mistakes can cost businesses big. From incorrect or delayed registration to miscalculations in VAT returns, many businesses struggle to get VAT compliance right, especially new startups unfamiliar with the thresholds.
Frequent VAT errors:
Solutions:
Virtue Accountants can simplify VAT processes so you can focus on growing your business, not wrestling with forms and figures.
Many businesses neglect to set aside sufficient funds for their tax obligations, leading to cash flow problems and stressful scrambling when payments are due.
Results of failing to plan:
Plan ahead by:
Virtue Accountants provides tax forecasting and financial planning services, helping you prepare for payments in advance and avoid cash flow headaches.
Right, so you've spotted a mistake on your tax return. Don't panic – you've got options, but timing is everything.
Now, here's where it gets interesting. If you've overpaid tax – maybe you forgot to claim some expenses or made an error that worked in HMRC's favour – you can claim overpayment relief going back up to four years. After four years, you can still try, but you'll need to show exceptional circumstances, and HMRC becomes much less accommodating.
The four-year rule applies to most situations, but there are exceptions. If HMRC discovers that you've been careless with your returns, they can investigate up to six years back. Deliberate errors or fraud? They can go back 20 years, and at that point, you're looking at serious penalties and potentially criminal charges.
HMRC's penalty system is based on your behaviour, not just the amount of tax involved. Think of it as their way of distinguishing between honest mistakes and deliberate attempts to avoid tax.
If you took reasonable care but still made an error – maybe you misunderstood a complex rule despite doing your research – there's no penalty. HMRC recognises that tax law can be confusing, and they won't punish you for genuine mistakes.
Careless errors are a different story. These are mistakes you could have avoided with a bit more attention to detail. Penalties range from 0% to 30% of the tax underpaid, with higher rates if HMRC has to prompt you to correct the error rather than you spotting it yourself.
Deliberate errors attract penalties of 20% to 70% of the underpaid tax. If you deliberately concealed the error – maybe by destroying records or providing false information – penalties can reach 100% of the tax involved.
The really serious stuff – deliberate concealment with intent to defraud – can result in criminal prosecution. We're talking potential prison sentences here, not just financial penalties.
HMRC's investigation powers depend on the type of error. Innocent mistakes give them a four-year window to investigate. Careless behaviour extends this to six years. Deliberate errors or fraud? They can go back 20 years, and there's no statute of limitations on criminal matters.
Sometimes HMRC gets it wrong too. If you disagree with a penalty or assessment, you don't have to just accept it.
Your first step is usually an internal review. You can ask HMRC to take another look at their decision, and a different officer will review the case. This is free and often resolves disputes without needing to go further.
If you're still not happy after the internal review, you can appeal to the Tax Tribunal. This is an independent body that settles disputes between taxpayers and HMRC. For smaller amounts (under £20,000), the process is relatively informal and you can represent yourself.
Time limits are strict though. You usually have 30 days from the date of HMRC's decision to request a review or lodge an appeal. Miss this deadline, and you'll need to show reasonable excuse for the delay.
Once you've identified an error, fixing it is usually straightforward. Here's how to go about it:
Online amendments: Log into your HMRC online account using your Government Gateway credentials • Select the tax year you need to amend from your account homepage • Click on "View and amend your return" • Make the necessary changes to the relevant sections • Check your calculations and review the updated tax calculation • Submit the amended return and save the confirmation for your records
Paper amendments: Download form SA302 or request one from HMRC • Complete only the sections that need changing • Clearly mark "AMENDED RETURN" at the top of the form • Include a covering letter explaining what you've changed and why • Post to the address specified in the guidance notes • Keep copies of everything you send
What happens after you correct: Once HMRC processes your amendment, they'll recalculate your tax liability. If you owe more tax, they'll usually add interest from the original due date. If you've overpaid, they'll either refund the money or offset it against future tax bills. Refunds typically take 3-5 weeks to process, though it can take longer during busy periods.
Prevention really is better than a cure when it comes to tax returns. Here are some practical steps to keep you on the right side of HMRC.
Good record-keeping isn't just about shoving receipts in a folder. Set up a system that works for you – whether that's a simple spreadsheet, accounting software, or even a dedicated app on your phone for capturing receipts.
Double-checking might seem obvious, but you'd be surprised how many errors come from simple typos or transposed numbers. Before submitting your return, go through each section methodically. Does that income figure look right? Have you included all your expenses? Are the dates correct?
Your Unique Taxpayer Reference (UTR) and National Insurance number are like your tax DNA – get them wrong, and your return might end up in someone else's file. Always verify these details, especially if you're using new software or filling out forms manually.
Professional help isn't just for big businesses. A good accountant or tax advisor can save you money by identifying allowances and reliefs you might have missed, whilst also reducing the risk of costly mistakes.
If you prefer the DIY approach, invest in proper tax software rather than trying to muddle through with basic spreadsheets. Most packages include error-checking features and are updated regularly to reflect changes in tax law.
Your tax code determines how much tax your employer or pension provider deducts from your income. Get it wrong, and you could end up owing money at the end of the year or missing out on refunds.
Check your tax code whenever your circumstances change – new job, pay rise, company benefits, or changes to your pension contributions. Your payslip should show your tax code, and you can check if it's correct using HMRC's online tax code checker.
Tax returns don't have to be a source of stress and sleepless nights. At Virtue Accountants, we've built our reputation on making tax compliance straightforward and stress-free for small business owners across the UK.
Our team understands that every business is different. Whether you're a sole trader juggling multiple income streams, a limited company director trying to optimise your tax efficiency, or a partnership dealing with complex profit allocations, we've got the expertise to keep you compliant and confident.
We don't just prepare your tax returns – we work with you year-round to ensure your records are accurate, your expenses are properly categorised, and you're taking advantage of all available reliefs and allowances. Our cloud-based systems mean you can access your financial information anytime, anywhere, and our mobile app makes it easy to capture expenses and invoices on the go.
Here’s how we can support you and help your business thrive.
What sets us apart is our proactive approach. We'll flag potential issues before they become problems, remind you of important deadlines, and help you plan for tax payments so there are no nasty surprises. If HMRC does come knocking, we'll handle the correspondence and represent your interests throughout any investigation or dispute.
Don’t wait for tax season to become overwhelming, reach out for a free consultation today. Our expert team is here to guide you every step of the way.
Making a mistake on your tax return isn't the end of the world, but it's not something to ignore either. The key is acting quickly when you spot an error, understanding your options for correction, and putting systems in place to prevent future mistakes.
Remember, HMRC's penalty system is designed to encourage compliance, not to punish honest mistakes. If you've taken reasonable care and can show that any errors were genuine oversights, you're unlikely to face significant penalties.
The most important thing is to learn from any mistakes and improve your processes going forward. Good record-keeping, regular reviews of your tax position, and professional advice when needed will serve you well in the long run.
Tax compliance doesn't have to be complicated or stressful. With the right approach and support, you can stay on top of your obligations and focus on what you do best – running your business.
Click below to find out more
Choose which package is right for you and get a quote.
Fill out our quick and easy online form. We promise it is easy!
Wait for a welcome pack, and let a dedicated account manager introduce themselves!
Tell us a little about your business so we can can create a package that is suitable for you.
